Hire Customer Care: A Practical, Numbers-Driven Guide to Building or Outsourcing Support

1) Define scope, channels, and coverage before you hire

Start with a precise workload definition. List the channels you’ll support (phone, email, chat, social, in-app), the hours of operation (for example, 8:00–20:00 ET Monday–Friday vs. true 24/7), and your target response times per channel. If you don’t have historical data, baseline with conservative assumptions: average handle time (AHT) of 5–7 minutes for phone, 8–10 minutes for chat (including concurrency), and 4–6 minutes for each email (including drafting and resolution). For new products, assume a 10–15% volume lift during the first 60 days after launch.

Estimate volumes by channel and day. Many B2C operations see a 15–25% spike on Mondays and a 10–20% spike after major marketing campaigns. New e-commerce brands commonly begin with 800–1,500 contacts per week; mid-market SaaS support centers may handle 3,000–8,000 per week. Define your service-level targets up front (for example, voice: 80% of calls answered in 20 seconds, chat: first response under 30 seconds, email: response in under 4 business hours). These targets drive staffing and cost more than almost any other decision.

2) Build in-house vs. outsource: costs, speed, and risk trade-offs

In-house hiring yields tighter cultural alignment and direct control, but it carries higher fixed costs and longer ramp times. Budget for fully loaded costs per agent that include wages, payroll taxes, benefits, equipment, software licenses, training, quality assurance, and workforce management. In the U.S., a common planning range is $3,800–$6,200 per agent per month (assuming $18–$24/hr base wages, 30–40% burden, $65–$150/seat/month for software, plus supervision and facilities). Expect 6–10 weeks from requisition to productive floor for net-new programs.

Outsourcing compresses timelines and converts fixed costs to variable. Typical hourly rates (all-in) are: U.S. onshore $28–$55 per agent hour; nearshore (Mexico, Colombia, Costa Rica) $14–$30; offshore (Philippines, India) $8–$18. Minimums often start at 3–10 full-time equivalents (FTE) with 90-day initial terms. Outsourcers bring QA, WFM, and training as part of the model, but require a strong statement of work (SOW) and a governance cadence to protect quality and brand voice.

3) Budgeting and staffing math that actually works

Translate your forecast into FTE using a few constants. Shrinkage (paid time not handling contacts: PTO, meetings, training, breaks) typically runs 28–35% for phone and 20–28% for email/chat. Occupancy (time spent handling contacts while logged in) should target 75–85% to prevent burnout. A simple planning shortcut: monthly productive hours per FTE ≈ 165 hours (based on 40 hours/week minus shrinkage). Total required FTE ≈ total workload hours per month ÷ 165, then add 10–15% buffer during ramp.

Example: You expect 1,200 phone calls/week with 6-minute AHT. That’s 120 hours/day of talk + wrap. With 80% occupancy, you need 150 staffed hours/day. If you operate 12 hours/day, that’s 12.5 concurrent agents on average. Accounting for 32% shrinkage yields roughly 18.4 scheduled agents to meet 80/20 service level. For monthly budgeting, 18.4 FTE × $4,800 per FTE per month ≈ $88,320 all-in. This excludes leadership (1 team lead per 12–15 agents) and shared roles like QA and WFM (often 1 QA per 12–20 agents, 1 WFM per 40–80 agents).

4) Roles, profiles, and compensation bands

Frontline customer care representatives (CCRs) should demonstrate strong written clarity (score 9/10 on grammar and structure), active listening, and system navigation speed. For U.S.-based teams in 2025, budget $18–$24/hour for entry-to-mid CCRs, with performance bonuses of 3–10% tied to quality and adherence. Senior or technical CCRs may command $25–$32/hour. Nearshore bands typically run $9–$16/hour, and offshore $5–$11/hour for comparable profiles.

Supervisory layers matter. A team lead typically earns $55,000–$75,000 base with a 5–10% bonus and owns 12–15 CCRs. A quality analyst ranges $55,000–$80,000, calibrated to channel complexity, with a target of 6–8 evaluations per agent per month. Managers overseeing 30–60 FTE often sit at $80,000–$120,000 base, with 10–15% variable tied to service level, CSAT, attrition, and cost per contact.

5) Recruiting and assessment that predicts performance

Time to fill for volume hiring averages 10–15 business days when your funnel is right. A practical process: day 1–3 sourcing; day 4–6 initial screen + language/writing test; day 7 role-play + systems simulation; day 8–9 references and background; day 10 offers. Maintain a 3:1 interview-to-offer ratio for quality control and a 1.2:1 offer-to-acceptance ratio by giving offer decisions within 24 hours of final interviews.

Use structured, job-relevant assessments: a 25–30 minute writing sample (respond to a complex customer scenario), a 10-minute data-entry and navigation test (target ≥ 6,000 KPH, error rate under 2%), and a live empathy/objection-handling role play. Require stable internet (for remote roles): 25 Mbps down/5 Mbps up minimum, jitter under 30 ms, ping under 60 ms, and a quiet environment standard.

• Screening rubric: communication (clear, concise, correct), problem-solving (identifies root cause, proposes 2+ options), customer orientation (uses names, sets expectations), and judgment (knows when to escalate). Score each 1–5; advance candidates scoring ≥ 16/20.
• Interview structure (45 minutes): 5 min intro and expectations; 10 min past behavior (STAR format); 10 min scenario role-play; 10 min tool aptitude (CRM mock task); 10 min Q&A and next steps. Decision within 24 hours; written feedback stored in your ATS.

6) Technology stack and integrations

Core stack for omnichannel: a CCaaS platform (voice/IVR/call routing), a ticketing/helpdesk (email, web forms, macros), chat/messaging with concurrency controls, and a knowledge base. Typical seat costs for CCaaS in 2025: $65–$150 per named user/month, plus telephony usage ($0.012–$0.030 per minute U.S. domestic). SMS runs roughly $0.0075–$0.015 per segment; WhatsApp templates may have additional per-message fees by country.

Integrate with your CRM and order/transaction systems to reduce handle time. Aim for screen pops with customer context under 400 ms to avoid agent delays. Invest early in a searchable knowledge base and response macros—teams that maintain 80%+ macro coverage for top 50 intents typically see 12–18% reductions in AHT and 2–4 point increases in first contact resolution (FCR). Enforce SSO, MFA, role-based access, and maintain audit logs for all data views and exports.

7) SLAs, KPIs, and quality management

Set channel-specific SLAs and tie them to business outcomes. Common starting points: voice 80/20 (80% of calls answered in 20 seconds), chat first response under 30 seconds with 2–3 concurrent chats per agent depending on complexity, email first response under 4 business hours and resolution within 1 business day for standard issues. For back-office tickets, set aging thresholds (for example, 90% within 48 hours, 99% within 5 business days) and publish daily dashboards.

Target outcome metrics that reflect customer experience and efficiency: CSAT ≥ 90% (or 4.6/5), FCR ≥ 75–85% (defined consistently), QA pass rate ≥ 90%, and contact rate ≤ 1.2 per order/subscription per month. Watch occupancy (75–85%), schedule adherence ≥ 92%, and agent-level attrition under 4% monthly rolling average. Use weekly calibration between QA, operations, and training to keep scoring consistent within ±5 percentage points across evaluators.

• SLA template: voice 80/20, abandon rate ≤ 5%, email first reply ≤ 4 business hours, chat first reply ≤ 30 seconds, average response time (ART) trend negative month-over-month, QA ≥ 90%, CSAT ≥ 90%, data breach = 0 (material breach clause), monthly service credit 5–15% for repeated SLA misses, with cure periods defined.
• Reporting cadence: daily service-level and backlog, weekly QA/FCR/AHT review, monthly business review with cost per contact, escalations analysis, and 90-day roadmap for deflection and quality projects.

8) Compliance, security, and data handling

Map your data flows. If you handle payment data, keep agents out of PCI scope via secure IVR or pause/resume recording; never expose full PAN. For healthcare, ensure BAAs are in place and systems meet HIPAA administrative, physical, and technical safeguards. If you serve EU or UK customers, implement GDPR/UK GDPR controls: data minimization, right-to-erasure processes, and defined retention (common support retention is 12–24 months, configurable).

For outbound or SMS, comply with TCPA and CAN-SPAM: maintain consent logs, honor opt-outs within 24 hours, and scrub against DNC lists. Background checks should be role-appropriate; at minimum, identity verification and employment history. Require SOC 2 Type II or ISO 27001 for vendors handling PII. Encrypt data in transit (TLS 1.2+) and at rest (AES-256), enforce least-privilege access, and review access quarterly.

9) Training, go-live timeline, and change management

A realistic new-team launch runs 6–10 weeks. Week 1: discovery, scripts, macros, knowledge base, and system access. Week 2: hiring and assessments. Weeks 3–4: training (20–40 hours product/process, 10–15 hours tools, 6–8 hours soft skills, 6–8 hours nesting). Week 5: soft launch on limited hours/channels with shadowing. Weeks 6–8: full launch with daily standups and rapid iteration on KB and macros.

Measure readiness: trainees must pass a knowledge check (≥ 85%), complete 10+ supervised contacts with QA ≥ 90%, and meet handle-time bands within ±20% of targets by the end of nesting. Publish change logs for policy updates and revise macros within 48 hours of discovering new top issues. Plan for a 10–15% productivity dip during the first two weeks post–go-live; schedule extra buffer staffing to protect SLAs.

10) Vendor selection, contracting, and pricing models

When outsourcing, issue a focused RFP that includes 30-day volume forecasts by interval, top 20 intents with AHT, desired SLAs, required tool stack, language mix, and security requirements. Ask for site options (onshore/nearshore/offshore), recruiting timelines, nesting plans, and three client references from your industry and channel mix. Evaluate vendors on total cost to achieve SLA, not just rate cards.

Common pricing models: per-FTE hourly (predictable scheduling), per-interaction (for email/chat where AHT varies), and per-minute for voice. For example, a 10-FTE program at $32/hour onshore equates to roughly $51,200/month per 160 hours/FTE, plus telephony and software passthroughs if not included. Negotiate ramp-down protections, a 30-day termination for convenience after the initial term, and service credits (5–15% of monthly fees) for repeated SLA misses. Include a quarterly price review tied to inflation or material scope changes.

Set governance rhythms: daily operations huddles during ramp, weekly performance reviews, and a monthly executive business review with action items and owners. Require access to raw interval data (15-minute granularity), QA artifacts, and call/chat transcripts for independent analysis. A strong SOW, clear metrics, and transparent data access will save more money and time than any rate negotiation.

What time does HireRight customer service work?

Monday-Friday, 6am to 5pm Central
Phone support is available Monday-Friday, 6am to 5pm Central Time. When the call connects, press #, then 1, then 5, then 2 to be connected with the HireRight Applicant Care Team for assistance.

What is the 10 rule in customer service?

When anyone comes within 10 feet of us, we make eye contact and smile; at 4 feet, we verbally greet them with anything from a simple “Hello!” to a friendly, “What brought you in today?” When used well, the 10-4 Rule helps create a positive welcoming environment, the kind of space where the best people want to work, …

What is HireRight customer support?

If you believe that any information in your background report is inaccurate or incomplete, you may request the correction of your information by contacting HireRight’s Customer Service at 866-521-6995 or [email protected].

How to hire a customer service representative?

Step-by-step guide to hiring for customer service roles

1. Define what skills and experiences your ideal candidate has.
2. Create a job description that attracts high-quality applicants.
3. Get your job post in front of your ideal applicants.
4. Evaluate applications.
5. Conduct interviews.
6. Have your best applicants complete a test project.